SC Lifts 30% Interest Cap On Late Payment Of Credit Card Bills

December 21, 2024 10:12

Illustrations: Dominic Xavier/Rediff.com

In a relief to banks, the Supreme Court on Friday set aside an order of the National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission (NCDRC) that capped credit card interest rates at 30 percent per annum on late bill payments.

The top court ruling has put an end to a 16-year-old case.

A bench of Justices Bela Trivedi and Satish Chandra Sharma was hearing petitions by banks such as Standard Chartered Bank, Citibank, American Express, and Hong Kong and Shanghai Banking Corporation (HSBC), which questioned before the court whether the NCDRC had jurisdiction to fix a maximum ceiling on interest rates to be charged by the lenders from their credit-card holders for their failure to make payment on the due date.

In 2008, the NCDRC had ruled that charging credit-card holders interest rates in excess of 30 percent per annum for failing to make the full payment on time, or only paying the minimum amount due, was an unfair trade practice.

However, banks argued that the advising interest rate is an occupied statutory field reserved by the legislature for the Reserve Bank of India to regulate, which is being done by the central bank.

They told the court that while fixing the maxima of interest rate, the NCDRC has not taken into account the fact that the levy of (higher) interest is only on defaulting customers and a compliant customer gets an interest-free unsecured credit for approximately 45 days, and also various costs associated with the credit-card business.

Meanwhile, the RBI had said that though it has directed banks to not charge excessive rates of interest, the policy is not to directly regulate the rates charged by the banks.

Therefore, the RBI left the matter to the boards of directors of the banks.

So, the RBI cannot be directed to issue any further instruction as it is a discretionary power conferred under the Banking Regulation Act, 1949.

In its order, the NCDRC had said: If the RBI is considered to be one of the watchdogs of finance and economy of the nation and the prevailing credit conditions are such as should invite its policy intervention, then, in our view, there is no justifiable ground for not controlling the banks, which exploit the borrowers by charging exorbitant rates of interest varying from 36 percent to 49 percent per annum, in case of default by the credit-card holders to pay before the due date.

The commission had also compared the interest rates of other countries, saying that Australia s rate of interest varies from 18 percent to 24 percent.

In Hong Kong SAR, credit card interest varies from 24 percent to 32 percent.

In the Philippines, Indonesia, and Mexico, which are emerging markets, credit card interest rate varies from 36 per cent to 50 percent.

However, the NCDRC went on to hold that there is no justifiable ground for adopting the highest rate of interest prevailing in smaller economies.

Experts say with the removal of the 30 percent cap, banks and financial institutions may have more flexibility in setting interest rates on late credit card payments.

This could lead to higher charges for consumers who miss payment deadlines, it also allows issuers to adjust rates based on market conditions and individual risk assessments.

Banks now have the flexibility to charge late payment interest rates higher than 30 percent.

This can significantly boost their revenue from credit card operations, especially from high-risk customers.Banks can set interest rates that align with individual credit risks.

Customers with poor payment histories may be charged higher rates, helping banks offset the risks associated with defaults.Banks can structure their credit card offerings more competitively without being bound by an arbitrary cap, said Gauhar Mirza, partner, Cyril Amarchand Mangaldas.

Sanjay Gupta, managing partner-dispute resolution, SNG & Partners, who had conducted the matter for banks before the top court, said: It is a welcome judgment passed by the Supreme Court today, and is a big relief for the credit card industry operating in the country. -- Bhavini Mishra/Business Standard

« Back to LIVE

TOP STORIES

Maha portfolio: Fadnavis gets Home, Ajit, Shinde get...

Shiv Sena's Dadaji Bhuse is the new school education minister while Uday Samant continues to be the industries minister.

Govt tweaks election rule; why is ECI afraid, asks Cong

Based on the recommendation of the Election Commission (EC), the Union law ministry on Friday amended Rule 93(2)(a) of the Conduct of Election Rules, 1961, to restrict the type of "papers" or documents open to public inspection.

Character assassination: Allu Arjun on stampede row

Hours after Reddy slammed the actor for holding a roadshow and waving to the crowds at the theatre, without referring to anyone, the 'Pushpa 2' star refuted the allegations and said it was not a procession or a roadshow.

Trudeau in trouble as ally vows to 'bring him down'

The future of Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau's leadership appears increasingly uncertain after New Democratic Party (NDP) leader Jagmeet Singh, a key ally, said he would introduce a motion to topple the minority Liberal...

Ferry passengers planned throwing kids into sea: CISF

A team of CISF marine commandos rescued dozens of passengers from a sinking tourist ferry off the Mumbai coast, preventing panicked parents from throwing their children into the sea. The commandos reached the accident site within minutes...