A new study suggests that firms using personalised marketing e-mails containing people's names, hobbies, and other personal information to pitch sales may be at risk of losing prospective customers.
"People bristle at personalization just for the sake of personalization. It comes across as too pushy. They want personalization that is relevant to them," said Tiffany Barnett White, a University of Illinois marketing professor who headed the research.
She said that personalised e-mails could click only if they offered value, and also quickly explain how personal information like buying tastes and leisure interests relate to the sales pitch.
"When messages are highly personalized, but lack value and justification, they have unintended effects. They can actually have a boomerang effect and cast the firm in a negative light, sending customers running to the competition," she said in the study report, which appears in Marketing Letters, a peer-reviewed journal.
During the study, undergraduate students were surveyed to gauge response to marketing e-mails with varying amounts of personal data, ranging from just names and hometowns to more detailed information like reading or cooking preferences.
The results of the study eventually showed that the degree of personalization was less important than whether the pitch had value, and whether it told customers how the deal and their personal information intertwined.
"If the offer was valuable and justified, the level of personal information didn't matter. Firms were no better off for throwing all of your personal information at you," Tiffany said.
According to her, the results of the study were surprising because it was purely based on personal data provided voluntarily, rather than from credit-card companies and other third-party sources.
Tiffany said that personalized e-mails without value might backfire, making consumers feel threatened by sales pitches they consider over the top.
"That can really give smaller businesses an advantage. At the extreme, it could make consumers go searching for competitors that they might not otherwise have gone searching for. Those smaller firms probably don't even have the technology to do that, and consumers find that somehow refreshing," she said.
"Nowadays, consumers are so much more savvy. They're so bombarded with tricks of this nature that they start to seem like tricks. So the onus in on marketers to convince consumers that this isn't a trick, that it has some value," she added.
Text: ANI
Image: Gyanendra Mishra, an engineer of the multipurpose organisation Mercantile Enter Service Provide, giving phone instructions to clients on how to download protection against the 'Red Worm' virus on their computer. | Photograph: Devendra M Singh/AFP/Getty Images
Also read: India's most dependable cars
Advertisement
