Over the last month, traders of commodities futures in India have been facing a market, which has been broadly disconnected from the movements in overseas markets. This is thanks to the fluctuation in the exchange rate of the INR. In this report, we delve into some statistics and fundamental factors that have been at play.
What's driving the INR to strength
Over the last two months, the Indian rupee has shown one of its sharpest waves of appreciation in history. The move has been literally a linear one with a surprising absence of central bank intervention. This never-before-seen move in the currency has startled and struck many traders and hedgers in Indian commodities markets.
In this report, we present some statistics and comparisons, which should help us in planning a better strategy in the coming months. To begin with, let us look at the factors that have been responsible for the Rupee's break-neck move.
Interest Rate Differentials
While the Indian monetary authority has been hiking rates, the developed economies have not been doing so. Over and above this, the monetary tightening through CRR hikes took up banks' lending rates further up, adding significantly to the cost of borrowings in INR. Thus, the rate differential between domestic markets and overseas markets such those of US and Japan widened considerably.
The active swap markets offered by Indian banks makes it possible for corporates to borrow overseas and thus swap it to rupees at an effective interest cost significantly lower than local costs. This practice has being growing rapidly and created huge inflows of USD into the Indian markets. This has not been a new phenomenon.
What's different this time is that RBI has completely stayed out of the market to absorb (buy) these dollars. As a result of this, we have only sellers of dollars in the market.
FDI and FII flows
Owing to the vibrant state of the domestic economy and the stock markets, we have also witnessed a spate of inflows from these two sources. NRI remittances have been sizeable as well.
Monetary Policy tightening
It is ironic but true. The Monetary Policy of recent months strived to tighten money supply by hiking reserves requirements along with raising interest rates. However, this has instead induced overseas funds to flush our markets and counter all tightening measures of the RBI. We must appreciate the fact that India's financial markets are now highly integrated to global markets and the doors for entry and exit of funds is much larger in size.
Purely domestic story
It is important to note that this move in INR has not been part of any broader global or Asian theme. The INR appreciation has been strictly an isolated case. In the past, whenever the INR has made big moves on it's own, they have been for it's weakening. This time it has been on the strengthening side and one with a historic magnitude.
Commodities - The disconnect
Let us now take a peek at the performance of some of the most active global commodities vis-a- vis on the local exchanges.
Commodity |
Price on 31.1.07 |
Price on 31.1.07 |
% Move |
INR |
44.07 |
40.89 |
-7.22% |
Gold Comex |
658 |
678 |
3.04% |
Gold MCX 9 |
9,423 |
9,098 |
-3.45% |
Silver Comex |
13.66 |
13.31 |
-2.56% |
Silver MCX |
20,299 |
18,252 |
-10.08% |
Crude Oil Nymex |
59.30 |
65.30 |
10.12% |
Crude Oil MCX |
2,563 |
2,703 |
5.46% |
Copper LME |
5,730 |
7,714 |
34.62% |
Copper MCX |
261.20 |
315.45 |
20.77% |
Zinc LME |
3,470 |
3,720 |
7.20% |
Zinc MCX |
160.95 |
151.45 |
-5.90% |
Now, we compare the actual per cent moves to the per cent moves actually implied by the movement in INR and international commodities.
Commodity |
Actual % Move |
Implied % Move* |
Gold MCX |
-3.45% |
-4.18% |
Silver MCX |
-10.08% |
-9.78% |
Crude Oil MCX |
5.46% |
2.90% |
Copper MCX |
20.77% |
27.41% |
Zinc - MCX |
-5.90% |
-0.01% |
Looking ahead for the rupee
The recent appreciation has been unprecedented and is considered extreme if seen in historical perspective. The sharp move has taken it to a level which is now 8.80 per cent away from its 200 dma (day moving average). The 200 dma generally acts as a strong anchor to most prices and any perpendicular move away from it will generally catch up gravity pulling it back towards the 200dma.
Whether, the INR pulls back to the 200dma or not is not really what we're looking forward to but the fact that the current level of the INR is most likely to be surpassed on the upper side within the next few days and possibly even a couple of weeks.
The 200dma itself has veered downwards very sharply, indicating that the medium term trend for the INR should be on the downside and 2007 will most likely be a year of Rupee strength. However, in the near term, we opine the INR to pullback just like a rubber band and test 42.00-42.50 before the end of May.