In an unexpected departure from the southern reserve Payne usually displays at his pre-US Masters news conferences, he said one of the world's most marketable sportsmen would be judged in the future by the sincerity of his efforts to change.
"Our hero did not live up to the expectations of the role model we saw for our children," said Payne.
"It is not simply the degree of his conduct that is so egregious here, it is the fact he disappointed all of us and more importantly our kids and our grand kids," he added.
The disgraced Woods is returning to professional golf this week after a break of nearly five months, following startling revelations he had had a string of extra-marital affairs.
"Is there a way forward? I hope yes," Payne said. "I think yes. But certainly his future will never again be measured only by his performance against par but measured by the sincerity of his efforts to change.
"I hope he now realises that every kid he passes on the course wants his swing but would settle for his smile," he added.
World number one Woods, whose golfing dominance has placed him in the pantheon of sporting greats since he turned professional in 1996, had his squeaky-clean image ripped apart after he crashed his car in the middle of the night in November.
EXTENDED BREAK
The bizarre incident outside his Florida home triggered a storm of media speculation over his private life and the 14-times major champion took an extended break from the game to try to repair his marriage to his Swedish wife Elin.
Woods, 34, admitted cheating on his wife and entered rehab for sex addiction before announcing last month he would return to competition at the year's opening major.
In a highly anticipated news conference at Augusta on Monday, he took full responsibility for the marital infidelities, which led to his fall from grace, and he pledged to be more respectful of the game.
"He forgot in the process to remember that with fame and fortune comes responsibility, not invisibility," Payne said.
"I hope he can come to understand that life's greatest rewards are reserved for those who bring joy to the lives of other people.
"We at Augusta hope and pray our great champion will begin his new life here tomorrow in a positive, hopeful and constructive manner but this time with a significant difference from the past," he added.
I was living a life of a lie: Tiger Woods
Elin set to divorce Tiger Woods: reports
Federer lends support to Tiger Woods
Spotted: John Abraham in Florida
It's golf or me, wife Elin tells Tiger