Order on plea against Kalmadi's Olympics visit reserved

The Delhi high court reserved its order on a plea to restrain sacked Commonwealth Games Organising Committee chairman Suresh Kalmadi from going to London to attend the 2012 Olympics to Wednesday.

"The order on the interim application is reserved for tomorrow," said a bench, headed by Acting Chief Justice A K Sikri after hearing a two-hour argument on lawyer Rahul Mehra's plea against Kalmadi's proposed visit to London for the sporting extravaganza.

"I'm not going to attend meetings in London on behalf of either the Government of India or any Indian sports body. I'm not carrying the badge of Indian representative in the Olympics," Kalmadi's counsel Mukul Rohatgi told the bench.

"I'm the president of Asian Athletes Association (AAA) and have been invited by International Association of Athletes Federation (IAAF), a foreign body which is not before this court," argued the senior counsel adding that his client Kalmadi's fundamental right to travel cannot be curtailed when he is assuring the court that he is going there on behalf of the AAA.

"What heavens will fall if some friend of mine gives me a ticket or I myself purchase a ticket and go there to watch a sporting event? This application is motivated and directed against me," Rohatgi said.

In reply to a query by the bench as to how Kalmadi became the AAA president, Rohatgi said the sports administrator was elected president of Athletic Federation of India in 2001 and became the AAA president the same year and as a consequence was invited by the IAAF.

"It seems even the foreign sporting bodies have the Indian tradition of electing members in perpetuity," Justice Sikri remarked.

At the end of the hearing, Rohatgi assured the court that Kalmadi will not watch any sporting event even as an invitee of IAAF, but he cannot be stopped from travelling and watching a game in his individual capacity.

Mehra, who filed the application opposing Kalmadi's London visit as part of another related petition, started the argument with a claim that Kalmadi can be and should be prohibited from going to London as his visit is not a personal one.

"India is one of the members of AAA, which has 44 other members and Kalmadi being the president of AAA cannot claim that he will not represent India there," Mehra said.

He also referred to various provisions of the Constitution of AAA and IAAF to drive home his point that on moral and ethical values, Kalmadi can be and should be restrained from attending London Olympics.

The court on July 18 had sought Kalmadi's reply on Mehra's plea for restraining him from going to London for the 2012 Olympics and had asked him not to advance his slated July 26 departure for it.

On July 13, a special CBI court allowed Kalmadi to go to London from July 26 to August 13 for the 2012 London Olympics.

Mehra has objected to Kalmadi's proposed London sojourn, contending that he is going to attend the games on public money and in violation of the International Olympic Committee (IOC) code of ethics.

He had sought the high court's direction to restrain Kalmadi from going to London on the ground that he is facing trial in a corruption case and cannot be allowed to represent the country in an international event.

The Lok Sabha MP and 10 others have been charge-sheeted by the CBI under various provisions of the Indian Penal Code and the Prevention of Corruption Act for allegedly "illegally" awarding a contract to install Timing, Scoring and Results (TSR) system for the 2010 Commonwealth Games to Swiss Timing, causing a loss of over Rs 90 crore to the exchequer.