Germany topped the group and will face the runner-up in Group H, while the United States finished second and will face Group H's winner.
Portugal, who beat Ghana 2-1, were eliminated with the Africans.
The Germans dominated the game with Juergen Klinsmann's team, with their backs against the wall, creating very few chances.
The breakthrough came after 55 minutes when Tim Howard parried out a Per Mertesacker header but Mueller collected the loose ball on the edge of the area and superbly side-footed into the bottom corner.
The game had been threatened by a torrential downpour in the north-eastern city of Recife on Thursday morning but the heavy rain that hampered the preparations of fans and players alike eased to a drizzle as kickoff approached.
Despite the fact that both sides only needed a draw to qualify there was no shortage of attacking intent in the lively opening exchanges, with Mueller going close early on from Lukas Podolski's low cross.
Both sides flew into challenges in the battle for supremacy in midfield, and U.S. coach Juergen Klinsmann and his German counterpart Joachim Loew will be glad the referee didn't wave the yellow card more often as they head for the knockout stages.
Content to concede possession for long periods, the Americans put in a blue-collar defensive performance, breaking forward when the opportunity arose, but with their superior technique and ball movement, the Germans were always a threat.
The Amercans had several chances of their own but lacked the pace and guile necessary to unduly worry German goalkeeper Manuel Neuer.
Image: Thomas Mueller celebrates scoring for Germany against the United States
Photograph: Martin Rose/Getty Images
Portugal win over Ghana in vain as both sides bow out
World Cup: Ronaldo returns as Portugal play to save campaign
PHOTOS: Portugal live to fight another day; Algeria thump Korea
World Cup PHOTOS: Record-equalling Klose salvages draw for Germany
FIFA World Cup: Who is shining, who isn't