The Premier League match between Everton and leaders Manchester City at Goodison Park was halted for around four minutes just before halftime on Tuesday when a male fan handcuffed himself to a goalpost.
The police said a 46-year-old man from nearby Southport was arrested for pitch encroachment and was being questioned.
City lost the game 1-0 and are now on the same points as Manchester United who defeated Stoke City 2-0 at Old Trafford.
Both teams have 54 points from 23 games but City lead on goal difference.
EPL: United join beaten City at top
Tevez could stay at Manchester City: Advisor
Death at Gadkari's home: What happened to Yogita, 7?
FA Cup: Van der Vaart lifts Spurs, Everton through
I-League: 10-man Sporting Clube hold Prayag United