A bench comprising justices J Chelameswar and R F Nariman asked the UP police to file response to the petition alleging that the Supreme Court advisory that section 66A of the Information Technology Act would not be invoked without consultation of high ranking police officers like the inspector general or deputy commissioner of police was violated. "We will examine," the bench said and posted the matter after four weeks.
Senior advocate Soli Sorabjee, appearing for the petitioner in the matter, drew the attention of the bench to the apex court's May 16, 2013, advisory which made it clear that no case would be lodged under the controversial provision of the law unless and until there is an approval from high ranking officers like the IG or DCP.
The counsel appearing for the UP government said that nothing has been left in the matter as the boy has been released on bail and there are remedies available to him under the law. When Sorabjee said that during the hearing of petitions challenging the validity of the section 66A of the IT act he should have pressed for the stay of the operation of the provision, the bench said, "Very often the laws are misused but we can not stay all laws because of being misused."
The SC had on Thursday agreed to hear the plea seeking explanation from the UP police on the matter in which a Std XII student was arrested for allegedly posting on Facebook 'objectionable' comments against the leader.
By the time advocate Manali Singhal made an oral mention of the application, news had reached that the 19-year-old youth was granted bail and would walk out of the jail shortly on completion of formalities.
A local court had on March 18 sent the Bareilly youth to 14 day judicial custody.
The present application questioning his arrest was filed by a Delhi-based girl and law student Shreya Shingal, who was the first person to file a PIL challenging the validity of section 66A of the IT Act. She has also sought amendment in Section 66A of the Act, after two girls -- Shaheen Dhada and Rinu Shrinivasan -- were arrested in Palghar in Thane district as one of them posted a comment against the shutdown in Mumbai following Shiv Sena leader Bal Thackeray's death and the other 'liked' it.
Image: A Std XII student was arrested for allegedly posting on Facebook 'objectionable' comments against UP minister Azam Khan
Youth arrested for Facebook post attributed to Azam Khan
Student arrested for Facebook post against Azam Khan gets bail
'My remark that Muslims won us Kargil should have been saluted'
Bangladesh to appeal over no-ball that saved Rohit
Govinda: I don't want to work with David Dhawan