Sherin's foster mother arrested for leaving her home alone

The foster mother of 3-year-old Indian girl Sherin Mathews found dead in a culvert in Dallas has been arrested and charged with child abandonment, with police alleging that the Indian-American couple left the toddler in the kitchen alone and went out for dinner.

Sini Ann Mathews and husband Wesley Mathews went out for dinner with their 3-year-old biological daughter October 6, the night before Sherin was reported missing by her adoptive father.

Sherin’s adoptive father, Wesley has already been arrested and charged with injury to a child, a felony charge. He is now in jail with a $1 million bond. The crime is punishable with up to 99 years in prison.

The couple from Kerala, allegedly left Sherin alone in the kitchen because she refused to drink her milk, police in Richardson, Texas said on Thursday.

The 35-year-old mother was arrested on Thursday when she turned herself in at the Richardson City Jail, escorted by her attorney.

She is being held on a charge of abandoning or endangering a child, a state jail felony. Bail has been set at $250,000, police said.

Sini, a nurse who works at Children’s Medical Center Dallas, could face different or additional charges, Perlich said on the case which has been widely reported in the
international media.

Sini appeared before a family court judge on Monday to attempt to regain custody of her biological daughter, who had been moved into foster care after Sherin’s death.

The toddler is expected to be moved at some point out of foster care to live with an extended family member in Houston.

A state jail felony in Texas is an offense that is punishable by confinement in a state jail facility from six months up to two years.

“This all stems from this ongoing investigation with Sherin. It’s sort of a culmination of everything we’ve got so far,” police Sergeant Kevin Perlich said.

“It was our decision that now was an appropriate time to make an arrest,” the Dallas Morning Post quoted him as saying.

Detectives determined Wesley and Sini went to a restaurant in Garland with their biological daughter, leaving Sherin home alone, placing her in “imminent danger of death, bodily injury, or physical or mental impairment,” according to the arrest warrant affidavit.

Cellphone records show both parents’ phones were at the restaurant that evening. A receipt showed only one child’s meal had been purchased, the affidavit stated. The waiter also confirmed that only one child was at the meal.

In an interview with detectives October 23, Wesley said that he and his wife had left Sherin, alone while the rest of the family went to eat dinner.

He said he became impatient when Sherin refused to drink her milk and went to dinner without her, the affidavit stated.

Wesley told detectives that he asked his wife to go with him and Sherin’s sister and Sini did so without being coerced, police documents state.

Police said they have not determined whether Sherin was alive when the couple returned home an hour and a half later, the Dallas Morning News reported.

An affidavit said the toddler was in the kitchen where they left her.

“The Dallas County Medical Examiner’s Office is continuing to work on determining the cause of death. Those results will be made available when complete,” Richardson Police said in a Facebook post.

Wesley had initially said he sent Sherin outside to an alley near their house about 3 am because she refused to drink her milk.

After Sherin’s body was found, he changed his story and to say he “physically assisted” Sherin with her milk, and admitted to removing her body from the home after she choked and stopped breathing, according to an arrest warrant affidavit.

Authorities launched a massive search and a dog found the body of a small child in a culvert on October 22. The body was later identified as that of Sherin.

Sherin’s death prompted External Affairs Minister Sushma Swaraj to ask the Indian embassy in the US to be actively involved in the case and keep her informed. She also sought a probe into the adoption process of Sherin, who was adopted by the Indian-American couple last year from Bihar.

Following Sherin’s case, India decided that passports to adopted children will be issued only with prior clearance by the ministry of women and child development.

IMAGE: Sini Mathews. Photograph: @RichardsonTX_PD/Twitter