Cabinet Secretary Ajit Kumar Seth, Defence Secretary Shashikant Sharma and Home Secretary RK Singh were taken by surprise when the Army's Northern Command told them that there had been no consultations on the subject of revocation of the AFSPA even once in 2011. The chief minister's declaration was totally unilateral, the three top secretaries to the Government of India were told.
The central team was told that it was way back in February that the Army had sent its views on the AFSPA and stressed the need to continue the Act's provisions in the state to enable Army troops to operate under a legal cover. But there were no consultations between the various stakeholders, defence ministry sources said.
In fact, during his visit to Kashmir, the defence secretary was given a separate three-hour presentation by the Army's top brass in Srinagar on the current security scenario in J&K.
In it, the army made it clear that the situation was under control and in parts of the state it appeared almost normal, but opposed any dilution or revocation of the AFSPA for the following reasons:
Abdullah's unilateral announcement caught the Centre by surprise although he insists that Home Minister P Chidambaram was in the loop on this issue and backs him fully.
Perhaps taken aback by the tough stand taken by the Army on the issue of AFSPA, Abdullah now says he only announced an intention and not a decision when he made that speech on October 21, declaring that "AFSPA will be revoked in the next few days."
Given the polarised opinion on the subject, the last word on the issue is clearly not yet uttered.
Removal of AFSPA not an effort to undermine the Army: Omar
AFSPA will be revoked from some areas in Kashmir: Omar
AFSPA issue under home ministry purview: Army chief
No need to withdraw AFSPA in J&K: Advani
Omar jumped gun on AFSPA, ordinary people paying price: PDP