Sources said Shah, who was home minister of the state in 2004 when the encounter took place, was quizzed after jailed IPS officer D G Vanzara claimed in his resignation letter that the Gujarat government was "inspiring, guiding and monitoring" every police action from "very close quarters".
When contacted, agency officers refused to confirm the report. No immediate comments were available from the agency spokesperson as well.
The sources said Vanzara, during his questioning by the CBI in Sabarmati Jail, has reiterated the stand taken by him in the resignation letter -- that police officials accused in various encounter cases were merely implementing the "conscious policy" of the state government towards terrorism.
They said the agency would be filing supplementary charge-sheets in connection with the encounter case, giving details of the conspiracy and alleged cover-up by officials of the Gujarat government.
Vanzara had claimed, they said, in the resignation letter that he and other accused officials had implemented the "conscious policy of this government, which was inspiring, guiding and monitoring our actions from very close quarters".
Vanzara, who is lodged in Sabarmati jail after the CBI named him as the main accused in the 2004 alleged fake encounter case, was quizzed about the content of his resignation letter, in which he also faulted Modi.
The 59-year-old former deputy inspector general of police sent his resignation letter on September 1, in which he expressed bitterness over the way the Modi government had failed to stand by him and other officers who implemented the state's "conscious policy" of "eliminating terrorism".
Shah, who is the BJP's Uttar Pradesh in-charge, has been charge-sheeted in other encounter cases of Sohrabuddin Sheikh and Tulsiram Prajapati. He was arrested in connection with the first case in July 2010 but later released on bail.
Exclusive Amit Shah Interview: People are waiting to vote for Modi
EXCLUSIVE: Anti-incumbency will wipe out the Congress: Amit Shah
Amit Shah incited communal violence in UP: Akhilesh
Exclusive! Not even a tiny taint on my kurta: Amit Shah
Innocent Rahul reads whatever is given to him: SP