BJP may pick new Uttarakhand CM if EC doesn't hold bypoll

Amid speculation over a change of leadership in Uttarakhand, Chief Minister Tirath Singh Rawat on Friday indicated that the Bharatiya Janata Party will take a call depending on the Election Commission's decision on holding a by-poll in the state.

Uttarakhand is abuzz with speculation that the BJP could pick a new leader as CM, given the possibility that the Election Commission may not hold a by-poll enabling Rawat's election to the state assembly.

Tirath Singh Rawat needs to be elected as an MLA in the next two months to continue in the post, which he got after the BJP leadership removed Trivendra Singh Rawat from the helm.

But observers say with the term of the assembly in any case coming to an end in less than a year, the EC may not order a by-poll for the vacant seats in Uttarakhand.

Scathing criticism by the courts of the string of elections held during the coronavirus pandemic may also contribute to the EC decision on Uttarakhand by-polls, it is felt.

Speculation over a change of guard in the state was fuelled by Rawat being summoned suddenly on Wednesday to Delhi, where he meet the BJP's top leaders including party president J P Nadda and Union Home Minister Amit Shah.

He was supposed to return to Dehradun on Thursday but stayed back.

After meeting Nadda on Friday, Rawat told reporters that it is the EC's prerogative to hold or not conduct the bypoll, and the party will move forward accordingly.

According to the Constitution, Rawat, an MP from Pauri Garhwal who was sworn in as CM on March 10, needs to become a member of the state assembly before September 10 to continue in office.

Section 151A of the Representation of People Act, 1951 mandates the Election Commission to fill vacancies in Parliament and the state legislatures through by-polls within six months from the date of their occurrence, provided that the remainder of the term of the new member is one year or more.

The term of Uttarakhand Assembly is scheduled to come to an end in March, only about nine months away.

Going by some Uttarakhand BJP leaders' interpretation, however, the law neither prevents nor makes it mandatory for the EC to hold bye-elections in such circumstances.

"It is within the scope and ambit of the Election Commission to take a call on whether or not to hold a by-poll in the state.

"Everything depends on the Election Commission of India," said Munna Singh Chauhan, BJP MLA from Vikasnagar and former spokesperson of the party's state unit.

Rawat has little to worry if a by-poll is held but doubts are being cast on its constitutional feasibility as the current assembly completes its tenure in less than a year.

There are two vacant assembly seats in Uttarakhand -- Gangotri and Haldwani.

Gangotri fell vacant after the death of BJP MLA Gopal Singh Rawat and Haldwani after the death of Leader of Opposition Indira Hridayesh.

Even if there are no constitutional hurdles, the Election Commission may not find it easy to go for a by-poll in Uttarakhand, observers here said, recalling court observations against the EC for 'risking' people's lives through elections amid a pandemic.

Political observers said the Centre may also not press for a by-poll in Uttarakhand as bye-elections are also due in other parts of the country and the hill state cannot be made an exception.

If a by-poll is not held then the only option left for the BJP's central leadership is to replace Rawat with someone who is already an MLA, they said.