Let us be realistic: looking at it from the perspective of a foreign observer not involved in the usual sparring of domestic politics, the Budget presented by Finance Minister P Chidambaram is very close to the maximum that could be expected in a difficult domestic and international context.
One can, of course, bemoan the absence of any new and significant reform.
However, this would be erring more on the side of wishful thinking than on the sober assessment of the very narrow margin of manoeuvre for the United Progressive Alliance government in the presentation of one of its last Budgets before national elections.
In fact, Mr Chidambaram had to perform a complex balancing act. On the one hand, sending a strong signal that he is committed to the top priority of reining current account and fiscal deficits - with the aim of bringing the latter down from 5.2 per cent to 4.8 per cent of the gross domestic product (GDP) for 2013-14.
India is not in a position to ignore or underestimate the risk of a downgrade.
On the other hand, he has to make sure that the cuts in government spending and increases in tax revenues presented in the Budget do not make it even harder to push growth from five per cent for the ending financial year - its lowest level for the last 10 years - to a relatively ambitious target of around 6.5 per cent for 2013-14, India also not being in a position to ignore the social and political risks of another year of economic stagnation.
In that respect, again from a foreign observer’s perspective, it is reassuring that Mr Chidambaram drew some lessons from the disastrous experience, verging on economic suicide, that Europe is experiencing.
His Budget is constructed to increase government expenditures and investment - especially in key areas such as infrastructure, education and health care - while increasing some tax revenues in a way that should normally be calibrated enough to avoid choking off investment and economic recovery.
As part of this balancing act come a number of measures to promote home ownership that should help support domestic consumption, to provide incentives for a revival of investment in the manufacturing sector which was completely stalled over the last year, and to attract more foreign investment in India’s financial markets by simplifying and streamlining some maddeningly arcane procedures foreign investors have had to go through until now.
What was especially heartening in Mr Chidambaram’s presentation was the blunt admission that “to be frank, foreign investment is an imperative”.
As a pragmatic, no-nonsense, political leader knowing fully well what kind of issues and obstacles are preventing foreign investors from a greater involvement in India, the minister realises that this kind of statement has to be forcefully illustrated and followed up by government actions.
It still remains to be seen, for example, how his reassuring signal on the Vodafone tax case will be translated into a solution to an issue that has rattled the international business community.
Beyond the Budget, these are the steps without which investors will continue to feel insecure - whatever the Budget’s
Budget 2013-14: Not a game-changer, but not trivial
FM's not so populist stand makes Bengal Inc happy
India Inc gives thumbs up to the Budget
Prudent Budget, says Gautam Adani
If I were the Finance Minister...